Is LASIK right for you?

Take the LASIK Eligibility Quiz

Which Cataract Lens Implant is the Best?

Key Takeaways

  • PanOptix Lens Success: The PanOptix trifocal lens provides clear vision at all distances and has a low rate of side effects, making it a top choice for many patients.
  • Vivity Lens for Professionals: The Vivity lens offers excellent distance and intermediate vision, ideal for pilots, truck drivers, and athletes, though it may require glasses for reading small print.
  • Outdated Lenses: Older lenses like ReSTOR and Crystalens, once revolutionary, have been surpassed by more advanced options, making them less valuable today.
  • Alcon AcrySof IQ Vivity’s Promise: The new Alcon AcrySof IQ Vivity lens has received positive feedback for its sharp distance vision, with only minor issues like temporary circles around lights.

Which Cataract Lens Implant is the Best?

I’ve implanted thousands of cataract lenses and have tried many different types over the years. Choosing the wrong lens can have serious consequences, leading to long-term discomfort and even decreased vision. The ideal lens should provide excellent distance, intermediate, and near vision with minimal or no glare. No single lens is a perfect match for everyone, as each one comes with its own benefits and risks.

The PanOptix Lens

One lens that has been very successful for many patients over the last three to four years is the PanOptix lens. This trifocal lens, the only one of its kind currently available in the US, provides clear vision at distance, intermediate, and near ranges simultaneously. This means you can switch your gaze from far away to your computer, phone, or a book without needing glasses. The PanOptix lens stands out for its clear vision and low rate of side effects, such as glare and halos.

The Vivity Lens

Another option is the Vivity lens, which is often recommended for pilots, truck drivers, and professional athletes. It provides excellent distance and intermediate vision, but for small print at close range or prolonged reading, glasses might still be needed. This lens uses a unique optical mechanism, making it less likely to cause problems like decreased vision or circles around lights. In cases where a patient has an issue with the PanOptix or another multifocal lens, switching to the Vivity has shown excellent results. It is also suitable for patients with severe dry eyes, macular degeneration, or glaucoma.

Lenses with Less Value

Some lenses do not offer as much value. The light-adjustable lens aims for perfect 20/20 vision for distance by adjusting the power of the lens after surgery. However, modern laser biometers are already very accurate in calculating lens power, so this feature is less useful. Similarly, older multifocal lenses like ReSTOR, Crystalens, and Symfony were excellent in their time, but better options are now available.

The New Alcon AcrySof IQ Vivity

A new lens that has been gaining attention is the Alcon AcrySof IQ Vivity. I started using this lens about two to three months ago, and the feedback from patients has been very positive. While it is not technically a trifocal lens, it offers good vision for distance, near, and intermediate ranges. Most patients report particularly sharp distance vision. Some do notice circles around lights, but these usually fade within a few weeks after surgery.

Patient Testimonial

Recently, a patient had the Alcon AcrySof IQ Vivity lens implanted in one eye and the PanOptix lens in the other. She reported that her vision has been wonderful since the surgery, with no need for glasses. She can read signs outside clearly and has no complaints. When asked which eye she preferred, she chose the right eye, which had the Alcon AcrySof IQ Vivity lens. However, she noted that this eye had more glare and halos, especially around lights at night.

Upon checking her vision, it was found that the distance vision in the right eye was clearer, while the near vision was equally good in both eyes. The right eye provided sharper distance vision but also slightly more rings around lights. Despite this, she mentioned that these rings did not bother her much, although they were noticeable at stoplights. If she had to choose the same lens for both eyes, she would opt for the PanOptix lens in the left eye because it did not produce circles around lights.

Final Thoughts

Your satisfaction with any particular lens depends on many factors beyond just the lens itself. The choice of surgeon and their experience with these lenses plays a critical role. Matching the perfect lens to your eyes relies on the surgeon’s expertise, your goals, and your eye condition. Choosing the right surgeon is a key factor for your satisfaction.

Curious about the costs of these lenses and what parts of cataract surgery are covered by insurance? Click on the next video to learn more.

Schedule Your Consultation & Comprehensive Exam